From the guide
News & guidance
Notes on choosing a prompt, meeting the rubric, and preparing for Defense Day.
-
HIR Defense Day: How to Answer ‘What Would Change Your Mind?’ (2027)
A practical guide to the counterfactual judge question at HIR Defense Day: prepare a 45–60 second answer that names the evidence, the source and the limit, so a concession narrows your thesis instead of erasing it. Includes a worked hypothetical answer and a rehearsal drill for Fall/Winter 2026 finalists ahead of 5 February 2027.
-
Is Your HIR Junior Invention Too Broad for 800-1,200 Words? (2026-27)
For the 2026-27 HIR cycle, a Junior Division invention is too broad when its causal story cannot be told with evidence inside 800-1,200 words. This guide gives a three-signal breadth check, a broad-versus-narrow teaching illustration, an evidence budget and a four-pass revision plan for Grade 7-8 writers.
-
HIR Evidence Fit: Does Your Source Support Your Claim or Only the Fact? (2026-27)
An HIR evidence-fit check asks whether the cited source licenses the inference in your sentence, not just the fact. This guide separates source fact, writer interpretation and warrant, works through an invented teaching paragraph whose number is accurate but whose conclusion outruns the evidence, and gives repair moves that fit inside 800-1,200 words.
-
HIR Junior Division: Pick an Invention You Can Support With Evidence (2026-27)
Pick an HIR Junior Division invention by testing one daily routine, a traceable evidence trail and rival explanations—before an 800-1,200-word draft begins.
-
HIR Rubric Calibration: A Three-Pass Self-Scoring Clinic Before You Revise (2026-27)
HIR rubric calibration means separating content scoring, style scoring, and evidence-based reconciliation before you revise. For the 2026-27 Fall-Winter cycle, use the verified 60-point frame: 12 rows scored 1-5, with Content 30 and Style 30. Self-scores are revision tools, not award forecasts.
-
HIR Citation Link Audit: Keep Hyperlinked Evidence Alive to Defense Day (2026-27)
A repeatable audit for every hyperlinked citation in a 2026-27 HIR Fall/Winter essay: check that each link still opens the page that still contains the exact fact, figure or quotation your sentence relies on, at the 2 January 2027 submission deadline and again before the 5 February 2027 Defense Day if you are a finalist.
-
HIR Essay Feedback Before You Submit: Briefing a Reviewer for Rubric-Specific Comments (2026-27)
A practical guide to requesting HIR essay feedback before submission: send a one-page reviewer brief, map comments to the 60-point Content and Style structure, and turn vague notes into revision actions without outsourcing authorship.
-
HIR Defense Day: A Fallback Protocol for Questions You Cannot Answer (2027)
A practical four-step fallback for HIR Defense Day: clarify the question, restate the essay's actual claim, name the limit, and bridge to evidence already in the submitted essay. For the Fall-Winter cycle, the essay deadline is 2 January 2027 and Defense Day is 5 February 2027.
-
HIR Essay Word Count Audit: Cutting an Over-Limit Draft Without Losing Rubric Points (2026-27)
A claim-first audit for an HIR draft over 1,200 words: build a cut ledger, protect the warrant, test a worked excerpt, and recheck AP style before submission.
-
HIR Defense Day Q&A: Build an Evidence Backup Sheet From Your Own Claims
A claim-by-claim method for HIR Defense Day Q&A: extract every factual and causal assertion from your submitted essay, record its source, scope, limitation, and backup evidence on one page, then rehearse honest answers to the follow-up questions your own limitations predict. Includes a template, labelled teaching mock exchanges, and script patterns.